Design Best Practice Self-Assessment Tool
Access the latest version of the Design Best Practice Self-Assessment Tool here.
Contents |
[edit] Background
Typically today:
- Construction projects have many quality metrics for the delivery phase but Clients have very few metrics for the Concept and Developed design stages of their projects.
- Evidence from projects, supported by analysis by the GIRI (Get It Right Initiative) in the UK, shows that the average construction project overruns its budget by 20% with worst case examples being 3-400% with time overruns of many years. The analysis concluded that many project quality issues have their root cause in the design stages of a project. Both the Client and the Architect processes often have a significant bearing on these issues.
In 2020, the Chartered Quality Institute published a piece of Quality guidance called the Construction Project Lifecycle which laid out the key Quality steps required to maximise the chance of success in construction projects. This guidance sparked wide interest and positive comments around the world. These interested people felt that more guidance about Quality Best Practices in the design stages of projects would be an extremely useful guidance tool.
[edit] The Best Practice Tool
This Quality Best Practice Self-Assessment tool (for Concept and Developed Design Stages) has been developed by a small group of leading quality experts from America, Australia, Canada & the UK, from a tool developed in the UK Airport Infrastructure industry.
The tool is aimed primarily at Construction Clients but can be used by Architects or Construction companies involved in the Concept and design stages of a project.
The belief is that use of this tool can significantly reduce the risks faced in projects by following well proven best practices developed from around the world. This will lead to major cost avoidance, timely delivery, and enhanced reputations.
[edit] When should this Tool be used?
The tool should be used during the Concept Design and Developed Design stages of a project (as defined by UK's RIBA organisation). Sometimes called Options and Scheme design stages.
The starting point is the Business Case approval Gateway (or some kind of project kick off decision.) That is: - a Client/Owner has had an idea, decided that it should be explored and set aside the necessary funds to develop a more detailed proposal.
At the end of the Concept stage, there may be a Recommended Option Approval Gateway before the commencement of the Developed Design Stage. On lower risk projects, this may also include funding for the entire project.
At the end of the Developed Design Stage, it is likely that the more detailed cost and schedule would be used to seek approval for the funding of the entire project.
After this (and not covered by this guidance) the project would move to production design, delivery stages and then to Handover and Operation/Maintenance.
[edit] How is the tool used?
The Tool is a subjective assessment of project progress made by the Project Manager, Quality Manager and a PMO representative.
It takes about 1-2 hours to complete and should be undertaken three times during each stage of the project.
The tool outputs a ‘percentage complete’ score. Experience has shown that projects with acceptable levels of risk have scores well over 90%. Any score lower than this should prompt many questions and careful risk assessment.
Access the tool here:
[edit] Contributors
Original work commissioned by Heathrow and lead by Helen Soulou with much input from Arup, Atkins and Jacobs.
The subsequent development of the tool has been undertaken by:
- Anita McReynolds Lidbury Arcadis (USA)
- David Myers Shirley Parsons Project Services (UK)
- Felipe Maya CIH - Construction Innovation Hub (UK)
- Greg Wennerstrom Calgary Light Rail Project - Canada
- Jonny Montgomery Shirley Parsons Project Services (UK)
- Martin Andrews Martin Andrews Solutions (Australia)
- Zoran Stojanovski AECOM (Australia)
Original article written by David Myers on behalf of the CQI Construction Special Interest Group and approved for publication on 4th May, 2021.
Version 2 of the Design Best Practice Self-Assessment Tool was made available 26/3/2022.
--ConSIG CWG 23:30, 16 May 2021 (BST)
[edit] Related articles on Designing Buildings
- 5 Whys
- Annex SL
- CDM Regulations: a quality perspective
- Change control: a quality perspective
- Checking and approval in design - a quality management perspective
- Collaboration: a quality management perspective
- Cost of quality.
- Design freeze: a quality perspective
- Design: a quality management perspective
- Quality Checklist
- Quality culture and behaviours
- Quality management systems (QMS) - beyond the documentation.
- Quality manuals and quality plans
- Quality tools: fishbone diagram
- Stakeholder management: a quality perspective
Featured articles and news
A case study and a warning to would-be developers
Creating four dwellings for people to come home to... after half a century of doing this job, why, oh why, is it so difficult?
Reform of the fire engineering profession
Fire Engineers Advisory Panel: Authoritative Statement, reactions and next steps.
Restoration and renewal of the Palace of Westminster
A complex project of cultural significance from full decant to EMI, opportunities and a potential a way forward.
Apprenticeships and the responsibility we share
Perspectives from the CIOB President as National Apprentice Week comes to a close.
The first line of defence against rain, wind and snow.
Building Safety recap January, 2026
What we missed at the end of last year, and at the start of this...
National Apprenticeship Week 2026, 9-15 Feb
Shining a light on the positive impacts for businesses, their apprentices and the wider economy alike.
Applications and benefits of acoustic flooring
From commercial to retail.
From solid to sprung and ribbed to raised.
Strengthening industry collaboration in Hong Kong
Hong Kong Institute of Construction and The Chartered Institute of Building sign Memorandum of Understanding.
A detailed description from the experts at Cornish Lime.
IHBC planning for growth with corporate plan development
Grow with the Institute by volunteering and CP25 consultation.
Connecting ambition and action for designers and specifiers.
Electrical skills gap deepens as apprenticeship starts fall despite surging demand says ECA.
Built environment bodies deepen joint action on EDI
B.E.Inclusive initiative agree next phase of joint equity, diversity and inclusion (EDI) action plan.
Recognising culture as key to sustainable economic growth
Creative UK Provocation paper: Culture as Growth Infrastructure.
Futurebuild and UK Construction Week London Unite
Creating the UK’s Built Environment Super Event and over 25 other key partnerships.
Welsh and Scottish 2026 elections
Manifestos for the built environment for upcoming same May day elections.
Advancing BIM education with a competency framework
“We don’t need people who can just draw in 3D. We need people who can think in data.”